Tourtiere: Quebec's Spiced Meat Pie for Christmas Eve
Ground pork and a whisper of clove, baked under a shatter-crisp crust

Contents
↓ Jump to recipeTourtiere is the dish every Quebec family argues about. Everyone agrees it belongs on the table; the fight is over whose recipe is the correct one. Ground pork simmered with warming spice, thickened with grated raw potato, baked between two layers of pastry until the crust turns a deep, matte gold: that much is common ground. Beyond it lies a genuine spectrum, from the clove-forward Lac-Saint-Jean version studded with cubed meat and potato in a much deeper dish, to the finer, spice-light Montreal style built almost entirely on ground pork. This is closer to the latter, a weeknight-manageable pie that still carries the spice signature that makes tourtiere unmistakable. For a fried take on meat in pastry, khuushuur are Mongolia’s deep-fried mutton pasties, thin discs of dough folded over spiced meat.
Quebec home cooks spice it properly, which is to say with real cloves and cinnamon rather than a token pinch, because a shy tourtiere tastes like an ordinary meat pie and misses the entire point. It shares its logic with chicken and mushroom pie in construction, a rich filling sealed inside pastry until it sets firm enough to slice, but the spicing puts it in an entirely different register, closer to a mincemeat than a stew.
Tourtiere: Quebec's Spiced Meat Pie for Christmas Eve
Per serving (1 slice (1 of 8)), estimated from the ingredients. Actual values vary with brands and portions.
The first quantity on each line is scaled. Check amounts mentioned inside a line, and cooking times.
Ingredients
- 500g minced pork, not too lean
- 250g minced veal (or use all pork, 750g total)
- 1 large onion, finely chopped
- 2 garlic cloves, finely chopped
- 1 medium floury potato, peeled
- 180ml chicken or vegetable stock
- 1/2 tsp ground cloves
- 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon
- 1/4 tsp ground allspice
- 1/4 tsp freshly grated nutmeg
- 1 bay leaf
- 1 tsp salt, plus more to taste
- 1/2 tsp black pepper
- 2 x 25cm shortcrust pastry discs (homemade or good shop-bought), enough for a double crust
- 1 egg, beaten, for glazing
Method
- Put the pork and veal into a large, heavy saucepan with the onion, garlic, cloves, cinnamon, allspice, nutmeg, bay leaf, salt and pepper. Pour in the stock and set over a medium heat.
- Bring to a simmer, breaking up the meat with a wooden spoon as it heats, then reduce to low, cover, and cook gently for 30 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the meat is cooked through and the liquid has mostly been absorbed.
- Meanwhile, grate the raw potato coarsely on the large holes of a box grater. Stir it into the meat mixture for the final 10 minutes of cooking; it will swell and thicken the filling as it cooks, binding everything together.
- Remove the bay leaf, taste the filling and adjust the salt and pepper; it should taste distinctly warm with spice, not sweet. Spread the mixture on a tray and let it cool to room temperature, then chill for at least 30 minutes so it firms up before it goes into the pastry.
- Heat the oven to 200C (180C fan). Line a 22 to 23cm pie dish with one pastry disc, leaving a small overhang. Spoon in the cooled filling and pack it in evenly.
- Brush the pastry rim with a little beaten egg, lay the second disc over the top, and press the edges together firmly. Trim the excess, crimp the border, and cut two or three small steam vents in the lid.
- Brush the whole top with beaten egg and bake for 20 minutes, then reduce the oven to 180C (160C fan) and bake for a further 35 to 40 minutes, until deep golden all over. Rest for 15 minutes before cutting, so the filling sets enough to slice cleanly.
Réveillon, and a pie built for the middle of the night
Tourtiere’s proper home is le réveillon, the late feast held after Christmas Eve midnight mass, a tradition that goes back to New France and the earliest Catholic settlers along the Saint Lawrence. Families would return from mass in the small hours of Christmas morning to a table already laid, and tourtiere, having simmered and baked while everyone was at church, was the meal built to be ready and satisfying at two or three in the morning without anyone standing over a stove. That timing explains a lot about the pie’s character: it reheats beautifully, it is dense enough to actually feed a returning, hungry congregation, and it holds its shape at room temperature for the hours a réveillon table might sit out.
The name itself is disputed in exactly the way you would expect from a dish this old. The most repeated theory ties it to the tourtière, a now-obsolete deep cooking pot used in early Quebec kitchens, rather than to the tourte, a game bird once used in the filling; either origin points to a dish already well established by the eighteenth century, long before pork became the default meat. Some regions still use game, wild rabbit or partridge folded through the pork, particularly around the holidays in rural Quebec, though supermarket tourtiere across the province is overwhelmingly pork and occasionally veal.

The spice question, and why restraint is the actual skill
Ground clove is the ingredient that decides whether your tourtiere tastes authentic or just like a peppery pie. It should register clearly on the first bite without dominating, a background warmth running under the meat rather than a dessert-spice note sitting on top of it. Cinnamon and allspice back it up in smaller amounts, and a few gratings of fresh nutmeg round the whole thing out; together they should read as savoury spice, the way a good curry powder reads as savoury rather than sweet, never as mincemeat or gingerbread.
The mistake most home cooks outside Quebec make is either skipping the clove entirely, worried it will taste like dessert, or overcorrecting so hard the pie tastes like a spice cabinet. Start with the quantities given here, taste the cooling filling before it goes into the pastry, and adjust by quarter-teaspoons; the flavour intensifies slightly as the pie bakes and rests, so a filling that tastes just-right off the stove will taste exactly right by the time you cut it.
Grated potato, and the case against dicing
Almost every tourtiere recipe uses potato as a binder, but the form matters more than most versions admit. Coarsely grated raw potato, stirred in for the final ten minutes of simmering, breaks down into the meat as it cooks, releasing starch that thickens the filling into a cohesive, sliceable mass rather than a loose, crumbly one. Diced or mashed potato, which some recipes call for, gives you visible chunks or a paste-like texture that changes the pie’s whole character; grated is the version that yields a filling dense enough to hold a clean slice without gravy pooling out.
Do not skip the resting and chilling of the cooked filling before assembly. A hot or even warm filling steams the base pastry as it bakes, leaving you with a soggy bottom crust under a good top; a properly cooled, slightly firmed filling goes in as a compact mass and lets the pastry crisp evenly on both sides.
Pastry, and the case against a fancy crust
Tourtiere pastry should be sturdy rather than delicate: this pie needs to hold its shape when sliced and served in wedges, sometimes at room temperature hours after baking, so an ultra-flaky, shattering pastry that collapses at the first cut is working against you. A standard all-butter or butter-and-lard shortcrust, rolled to a workmanlike 3 to 4mm rather than paper-thin, gives you the structural integrity the dish actually needs. If you want extra richness, a portion of lard alongside the butter is traditional and gives the crust a slightly more savoury edge that suits the spiced filling, the same instinct behind a proper hand-raised pork pie crust.
Crimp the edges firmly and cut real steam vents; a sealed pie with no escape for steam will crack unpredictably across the top as it bakes, and the filling can force its way out through the weakest point in the crust rather than the vents you cut deliberately.
Pork alone versus pork and veal
Using both pork and veal, rather than pork on its own, is a choice worth defending. Veal brings a lighter, more delicate flavour and a slightly looser texture that keeps the filling from turning dense and one-note, the way an all-pork filling can if the pork is on the fattier side. It is closer to how many Montreal households actually make the pie, blending the two meats rather than treating pork as the only option. If veal is hard to find or you would rather not buy it, all pork works perfectly well; choose mince that is not too lean, since a little fat carries the spice through the filling and keeps the finished pie from tasting dry once it has cooled and been sliced.
Some cooks add a small amount of beef in place of the veal for a deeper, more savoury filling, though this pulls the flavour further from the classic Quebec profile and closer to an ordinary spiced meat pie. If you go that route, lean slightly harder on the clove to keep the tourtiere identity intact, since beef’s stronger flavour can otherwise flatten the spice into the background.
Lac-Saint-Jean tourtiere, a different animal entirely
It is worth knowing that the pie described here, thin, pastry-heavy, built on finely ground meat, is only one branch of the tourtiere family. Head three hours north to the Lac-Saint-Jean region and you find a dramatically different dish under the same name: a deep-dish pie, often baked in a roasting tin rather than a standard pie plate, layered with cubed rather than ground meat, potato, and sometimes a mix of pork, beef and game, all left to marinate overnight before a long, slow bake of several hours under a thick crust. It eats more like a cassoulet in pastry than the finer, quicker pie in this recipe.
Neither version is more correct than the other; they simply come from different culinary traditions within the same province, and Quebecers are generally happy to defend whichever one their own family makes. This recipe follows the more widespread, home-cook-friendly Montreal-style approach, which is the version most likely to appear on a réveillon table outside Lac-Saint-Jean itself and the one that fits comfortably into a weeknight without an overnight marinade or a multi-hour bake.
Serving, storage and the ketchup debate
Tourtiere is traditionally served with a tangy condiment on the side, most commonly a homemade fruit chutney or a simple green tomato relish; some families do reach for plain ketchup, a point of genuine, semi-serious dispute across Quebec kitchens, and there is no wrong answer here beyond having something acidic on the table to cut the richness of the pastry and spiced meat.
The pie keeps beautifully. Wrapped and refrigerated, it holds for up to four days, and it reheats well in a moderate oven, loosely covered with foil for the first ten minutes so the top does not scorch before the centre warms through. It also freezes unbaked: assemble the pie completely, wrap it tightly, and freeze for up to two months, baking from frozen with an extra 20 to 25 minutes added and the oven at the same two-stage temperature. However you serve it, tourtiere is a dish built for a table with more than one generation sitting at it, spiced enough to be memorable and sturdy enough to survive being made hours, or a season, ahead.




